Student Satisfaction

STUDENT SATISFACTION reflects the effectiveness of all aspects of the educational experience. The goal is that all students who complete a course express satisfaction with course rigor and fairness, with professor and peer interaction, and with support services. Online students put a primary value on appropriate, constructive, and substantive interaction with faculty and other students. Effective professors help students achieve learning outcomes that match course and learner objectives by using current information and communications technologies to support active, individualized, engaged, and constructive learning. As consumers, students are satisfied when provider services-learning resources, academic and administrative services, technology and infrastructure support -- are responsive, timely, and personalized. Effective practices may analyze and apply the results of student and alumni surveys, referrals, testimonials or other means of measuring perceived satisfaction with learning communities. Student satisfaction is the most important key to continuing learning.
Volume, Issue - Date: 
Volume 8, Issue 2 - April 2004
Author(s): 
D. Randy Garrison, University of Calgary
Author(s): 
Martha Cleveland-Innes, Athabasca University
Author(s): 
Dr. Tak Fung, University of Calgary
Full article - Free: Click on the file to download.: 
Keywords: 
student satisfaction, role adjustment, community of inquiry, learning effectiveness, online learning
Abstract: 

The purpose of this study is to validate an instrument to study role adjustment of students new to an online community of inquiry. The community of inquiry conceptual model for online learning was used to shape this research and identify the core elements and conditions associated with role adjustment to online learning (Garrison, Anderson and Archer, 2000). Through a factor analytic process it is shown that the instrument did reflect the theoretical model. It was also useful in refining the items for the questionnaire. The instrument is for use in future research designed to measure and understand student role adjustment in online learning.

Volume, Issue - Date: 
Volume 8, Issue 2 - April 2004
Author(s): 
David DiBiase, John A. Dutton e-Education Institute, College of Earth and Mineral Sciences, The Pennsylvania State University
Full article - Free: Click on the file to download.: 
Keywords: 
faculty satisfaction, faculty workload, efficiency, scalability, student satisfaction, asynchronous online course, distance education
Abstract: 

Detailed daily records of instructor effort in an established asynchronous online course over a three and one-half year period are analyzed. Student satisfaction data acquired from course evaluation surveys over the same period are also examined. In response to a three-fold increase in enrollment over the period, instructors realized a twelve percent gain in efficiency. Contrary to expectations, a modest economy of scale was achieved with no discernible decrease in student satisfaction.

Volume, Issue - Date: 
Volume 8, Issue 3 - June 2004
Author(s): 
James Theroux, Isenberg School of Management, University of Massachusetts
Author(s): 
Cari Carpenter, Isenberg School of Management, University of Massachusetts
Author(s): 
Clare Kilbane, School of Education, University of Massachusetts
Full article - Free: Click on the file to download.: 
Keywords: 
student satisfaction, real-time, live case study
Abstract: 

A new type of case study, called the real-time case (RTC), was produced in the fall of 2001 and distributed via the Internet to business classes at four universities in the US and Canada. The real-time case presented the story of one company's growth and development throughout a 14-week semester. A case writer stationed full-time at the subject company published case installments weekly on the Web, allowing students to view Volumethe company-building process as it happened. The 14-week coverage of RTC enabled students to study the subject company in unprecedented depth and detail. RTC's real-time interactivity allowed students to share their analyses and best thinking with the company leadership during the company’s decision-making process.

 

A major objective in producing the case was to heighten student engagement with the case material. To evaluate whether this objective was achieved, a survey and a focus group discussion were conducted with one of the participating MBA classes. Results from the survey and the focus group showed a high degree of engagement, plus many other benefits from the new type of case study.

Volume, Issue - Date: 
Volume 8, Issue 4 -December 2004
Author(s): 
Pedro A. Willging, Department of Human Resource Education, University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign
Author(s): 
Scott D. Johnson, Department of Human Resource Education University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign,
Full article - Free: Click on the file to download.: 
Keywords: 
student satisfaction
Abstract: 

Although there are many reasons why students dropout of college courses, those reasons may be unique for students who are enrolled in an online program. Issues of isolation, disconnectedness, and technological problems may be factors that influence a student to leave a course. To understand these factors, an online survey was developed to collect data from students who dropped out of an online program. Logistic regression analysis was used to compare various factors between those who persist in the program and those who dropout. The results, based on the dropouts from three cohorts in an online graduate program, show that demographic variables do not predict likelihood of dropping from a program. Instead, the students’ reasons for dropping out of an online program are varied and unique to each individual. Recommendations for further study are incorporated in the conclusions.

Volume, Issue - Date: 
Volume 8, Issue 4 - December 2004
Author(s): 
Minjuan Wang, San Diego State University
Full article - Free: Click on the file to download.: 
Keywords: 
student satisfaction, online visibility, learning outcomes, communication tools and online socialization, students' self- perception
Abstract: 

This study examines the relationship between student visibility and learning outcomes in a graduate-level online course. Visibility in this study refers to students’ cognitive, social, and emotive presence [1, 2] in various communication settings, such as posts on the discussion board, contributions in live chats, email messages, online profiles, and inputs via any other means of communication. A visibility score is determined for each student, and the Spearman r correlational tests are used to detect any significant correlation between visibility and learning outcomes (grades). In addition, two surveys were distributed to the students at the end of the course: (a) Survey on Self-Perception on Learning Experiences provides a context for understanding student performance; and (b) Survey on Useful Aspects of Socializing Online asks students to rank the importance of eight types of online activities, such as sharing information, solving problems, and making friends. Both surveys probe into students’ perceptions and social context, which often have great impact on students’ online presence.

Author Information
Author(s): 
Karen Swan, Kent State University
Institution(s) or Organization(s) Where EP Occurred: 
Athabasca University, Centre for Innovative Management, Canada
Effective Practice Abstract/Summary
Abstract/Summary of Effective Practice: 

The Orientation course improves learning effectiveness because the content is geared towards learning important course navigation skills, practising online collaboration, and building student confidence for new graduate students. We are able to address student concerns and anxieties up front, before they start their academic courses, and we are able to ensure that students are set up properly in terms of the technology, so that they can start their first academic course (Strategic Management) and "hit the ground running."

Supporting Information for this Effective Practice
Evidence of Effectiveness: 

The results from the 2004 Orientation courses (n=102) using pre- and post-orientation survey questions indicated that the Orientation course increased student confidence, academic skill development, effective time management skills, and the development of technology skill sets that promote and support successful participation in online learning environments. This was most evident in the results to the survey question where 98/102 students (96.1%) strongly agreed that "Having completed the Orientation week, I feel more comfortable starting the MBA program than I would have without the orientation."

How does this practice relate to pillars?: 

learning effectiveness Students complete a one-week online MBA Orientation course immediately before they start the Executive MBA program and their required academic courses. Students interact with each other and their academic "coach" using the learning platform and tools they are expected to use during their academic courses. By mirroring the structure of the Orientation course to that of an online MBA academic course, students can not only practice and familiarize themselves with the learning platform and tools, but can also pace their readings and assignments during the week as they would for an eight-week course. Students learn how to participate in asynchronous online discussions by reading a short article on the merit of case study analysis (an important aspect of the MBA program) and they then discuss the merits and disadvantages of learning from case studies with their academic coach and fellow students. Students practice writing and submitting assignments by reading a short article on Lotus Notes®, summarizing a 100-word response on it, and submitting their assignment to their academic coach. Students also read an Internet article on time management and submit the appropriate American Psychological Association (APA) reference for the article. Although the assignments are not graded, students do receive generalized feedback on their submissions. The Orientation course also introduces students to some key university policies (such as academic conduct) and students learn how to navigate library databases. By completing the orientation, students are ready to concentrate on learning the content of their courses instead of having to divide their attention between learning the mechanics (expectations as well as interface) and learning the content.

Estimate the probable costs associated with this practice: 

The cost is low because we have one MBA graduate function as the Orientation coach for each intake. The cost to students is also low because we do not charge students for the Orientation course and yet it saves them considerable time while reducing their anxieties and concerns about the program.

References, supporting documents: 

Hansen, D., Maushak, N. J., Schlosser, C. A., Anderson, M. L., Sorenson, C., & Simonson, M. (1997) Distance Education: Review of the Literature (2nd ed) (Washington, D.C.: Association for Educational Communications and Technology)

Contact(s) for this Effective Practice
Effective Practice Contact: 
Kam Jugdev, PhD, PMP
Email this contact: 
kamj@athabascau.ca
Effective Practice Contact 2: 
Maureen Hutchison, BA
Email contact 2: 
maureenh@athabascau.ca
Volume, Issue - Date: 
Volume 4, Issue 2 - September 2000
Author(s): 
Eric Fredericksen, State University of New York
Author(s): 
Alexandra Pickett, State University of New York
Author(s): 
Peter Shea, State University of New York
Author(s): 
William Pelz, Herkimer County Community College
Author(s): 
Karen Swan, University of Albany
Full article - Free: Click on the file to download.: 
Keywords: 
student satisfaction
Abstract: 

The State University of New York (SUNY) Learning Network (SLN) is the on-line instructional program created for the 64 colleges and nearly 400,000 students of the SUNY. The foundation of the program is freedom from schedule and location constraints for our faculty and students. The primary goals are to bring SUNY's diverse and high-quality instructional programs within the reach of learners everywhere and to be the best provider of asynchronous instruction for learners in New York State and beyond.

We believe that these goals cannot be achieved unless learning effectiveness is given top priority. This paper will examine factors that have contributed to the high levels of learning and learner satisfaction that students have reported in the SLN. The analysis will be done on several levels. The first section will look at the SLN at a program-wide level and will provide information regarding the systemic implementation of our asynchronous learning environment.

The second section examines issues that contribute to learning effectiveness from a faculty-development and course-design perspective. This section will present the evolution of the four-stage faculty development process and a seven-step course design process that was developed by SLN and comment on lessons learned.

The third section presents results from the SLN Student Satisfaction Survey conducted in spring 1999. This section examines factors from a quantitative analysis that significantly contributes to perceived learning and student satisfaction in on-line asynchronous courses and offers recommendations for course and program design based on these factors.

The fourth section examines learning effectiveness at the level of individual institutions through examples from specific courses. This section will introduce the reader to local implementation of SLN courses at two colleges programs in the SUNY system, the Curriculum Design and Instructional Technology program at the University at Albany (UA) and the Internet Academy (IA) of Herkimer County Community College (HCCC). These case studies present and examine important evidence relevant to learning effectiveness from a single-institution and individual-faculty perspective.

With generous support from the Alfred P. Sloan Foundation, combined with enthusiasm and resources from SUNY System Administration and participating campuses, the SLN has successfully met the challenges of the initial developmental phases that focused on proof of concept and expansion/scalability. The annual growth in courses, from eight in 1995-96 to 1000 in 1999-2000, and annual growth in enrollment, from 119 in 1995-1996 to over 10,000 in 1999-2000, illustrates that the project has far exceeded the original projections.
The SLN started as a regional project in the Mid-Hudson Valley involving eight SUNY campuses. At that time, the development and delivery of asynchronous courses was a new activity for SUNY campuses and faculty. The first courses were offered in the 1995-1996 academic year.

Successful experiences led to an expanded vision and goals for the SLN and the scope and objectives of the project have grown substantially. Where we originally developed courses at the third- and fourth-year level - offered by two of our institutions - we are now offering courses at all undergraduate levels as well as the graduate level and 42 of our institutions are involved. Our initial developmental phase focused on proof of concept within the SUNY system. This was followed by a phase that focused on proof of scalability that achieved significant growth in course offerings and student enrollments. SUNY's efforts continue to evolve the SLN from a project status to a fully integrated, virtual learning component responsive to the needs of learners in the new millennium. Ultimately, the SLN will represent the entire SUNY through the creation of one virtual campus that will be open seven days a week, 24 hours a day to students across the globe. The SLN primary mission is to bring SUNY's high quality instructional programs within reach of learners anywhere. Another objective has been to take an efficient approach in supporting the SUNY campuses. Rather than each campus reinventing the wheel, SLN has developed and implemented the appropriate operational services and support yielding both cost savings as well as the sharing of experience from one campus to another. SLN has traditionally assisted campuses to conduct individual course evaluations. Additionally, the SLN office conducted two program-level student surveys and one faculty survey during the 1998-99 academic year. The goal of the student surveys was to gauge the level of student satisfaction with SLN, perceived learning with SLN, and what factors contributed to those results. The results of this survey are presented in this paper.

Volume, Issue - Date: 
Volume 6, Issue 1 - July 2002
Author(s): 
John Dutton, College of Management, North Carolina State University
Author(s): 
Marilyn Dutton, School of Business, North Carolina Central University
Author(s): 
Jo Perry, TogetherSoft Corporation,
Full article - Free: Click on the file to download.: 
Keywords: 
learning effectiveness, access, student satisfaction, distance education, internet
Abstract: 

This study has two primary objectives. First, we want to know how students who enroll in online classes differ from their peers in traditional lecture classes. Our second objective involves both exploring what factors influence performance among online students, as well as whether those factors differ for online and lecture students. Our comparisons are of two large sections of a course in computer programming for which almost the only difference was that one section consisted of on-campus lectures, and the other section was online. We find that online students do differ from lecture students in a number of important characteristics. However, when we examine class performance and course completion, we find that the factors which influence performance seem to have a stronger impact on lecture students, but we cannot reject the hypothesis that factor coefficients are the same for the two groups.

Volume, Issue - Date: 
Volume 9, Issue 1 - March 2005
Author(s): 
David M. Anderson, Department of Educational Leadership and Counseling, Eastern Michigan University
Author(s): 
Carol J. Haddad, Department of Interdisciplinary Technology, Eastern Michigan University
Oganization: 
Eastern Michigan University
Full article - Free: Click on the file to download.: 
Keywords: 
student satisfaction, online teaching, online learning, women, gender, voice, postsecondary education
Abstract: 

A self-selected sample of 109 online students at a midwestern regional university was surveyed and asked to compare expression of voice, control over learning, and perceived deep learning outcomes in face-to-face versus online course environments. We found that females experience greater perceived deep learning in online than in face-to-face courses, and that expression of voice appears to contribute to this outcome. This effect did not occur for male students. We also found that professor support and, to a lesser extent, control over one's learning each had positive relationships with perceived deep learning in both course environments. Concern for the feelings of other students did not have a negative impact on voice as was originally hypothesized.

Author Information
Author(s): 
Janet Moore
Author(s): 
The Sloan Consortium
Institution(s) or Organization(s) Where EP Occurred: 
University of North Texas
Effective Practice Abstract/Summary
Abstract/Summary of Effective Practice: 

-

Description of the Effective Practice
Description of the Effective Practice: 

Introduction: UNTeCampus [1] is the student's guide for finding out about online and videoconference courses and programs. UNTeCampus meets all five pillars of quality by providing access to course information for online students, student satisfaction in knowing that they are prepared for the academic and technical requirements of the online course, learning effectiveness in permitting students to get a head start on course requirements, faculty satisfaction in knowing that their students know and are prepared to meet the course's expectations; and cost effectiveness and institutional commitment in making course and program information available to prospective and current students before they make a decision about entering a specific course or program. Access: UNTeCampus electronically provides course information including the course catalog description, section number, delivery method, instructor's name, location of any face-to-face meetings, course objectives, course expectations, tests and quizzes, major assignments, software and hardware needed, student/instructor communication methods, textbooks, enrollment restrictions, and other requirements to the prospective student. Program information is submitted to UNTeCampus when the degree is approved for electronic delivery. Student Satisfaction: UNT current students and prospective students appreciate the opportunity to find information about all online courses in one location in time to make registration decisions about the next semester. The Student Services (admissions, financial aid, tuition and fees, registrar's office,library services, bookstore links), Frequently-asked Questions (such as transfer, transient, and military students, WebCT questions, and core course information), and Directory of UNT Services for Online Students (directories, career services, counseling, health and wellness, legal, student accounting, etc.)answer most student questions. Additional questions are answered individually on a daily basis through Contact Us. Learning Effectiveness: Because students are prepared with textbooks, learning objectives, syllabi, course expectations, face-to-face meeting dates (if any), technical and other course requirements before the first day of class, they are able to successfully begin the course the first day it opens. Documented success rates in online and face-to-face courses are very similar. Faculty Satisfaction: The course information is electronically submitted into the Course Information Database (http://www.unt.edu/cid) by the course instructor before early registration begins. To encourage early submission, faculty members are given a deadline and a gift packet (UNTeCampus promotional items) for meeting the submission deadline. Normally, 85-90% of courses are listed by early registration. Faculty know that entering their course information on UNTeCampus will also result in their courses being included in the TexasDistanceEducation, SREB Electronic Campus, and other online information resources. Faculty also appreciate the opportunity to answer many frequently-asked questions once through UNTeCampus rather than responding to individual student requests asking the same questions over and over. Cost Effectiveness and Institutional Commitment: The availability of online program and course information through UNTeCampus increases the likelihood that distance students will enroll in the programs and courses. If the students live more than 50 miles from campus, 83% of their tuition is returned to the teaching department, which then provides funds for the creation of more online courses, hiring of additional adjunct faculty and teaching assistants, and availability of additional student advising, materials, and equipment. The Center for Distributed Learning provides high-quality instructional design and production for online courses, which are then made available to other institutions through licensing agreements.